Return to Respiratory Advisor Homepage Respiratory Protection Advisor

Chapter 3 - Respirator Selection

User Guide
Site Map
Comments

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I. Regulatory Requirements

The selection, use, and maintenance of respirators in the United States is presently regulated by several Federal agencies. The agencies, the acts which authorize their activities, and the current regulations relating to selection, use, and maintenance of respirators, are as follows.

Act Agency Regulation(s)
Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977 Mine Safety and Health Administration; Department of Labor Title 30 CFR Parts 11, 70
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control, Department of Health and Human Services Title 30 CFR Part 11
Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 Occupational Safety and Health Administration, Department of Labor Title 29 CFR Part 1910
Toxic Substances Control Act Environmental Protection Agency Title 40 CFR Part 750
Title II of the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Title 10 CFR Part 20

The Federal regulations cited above and Guidelines issued in accordance with those regulations, with few exceptions, call for selection and use of respirators that have been certified by MSHA and NIOSH. Exceptions to that principle include the MSHA allowance of use of certain Bureau of Mines-approved mine rescue breathing apparatus, the OSHA acceptance of cylinder interchange and "buddy breathing systems" for use by fire fighters in 29 CFR 1910.156, and the NRC acceptance of supplied-air suits tested by Los Alamos National Laboratory.

Since 1972, with promulgation of Title 30 CFR 11, MSHA and NIOSH have tested and certified various types of respiratory protective devices. The present regulations in Part 11 are the result of amendment of the 1972 regulation. NIOSH currently recognizes that certain requirements of Part 11 are inadequate and incomplete, and a proposed revision of Part 11 has been published for public comment as a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking 42 CFR Part 84. Final publication is expected following a public hearing and further revision of Part 84.

II. General Selection Information

NIOSH recommends that respirators only be used when engineering controls are not feasible or effective, while controls are being installed or repaired, or for emergency and other temporary (intermittent) situations. Respirator selection is very complex and should be performed by an Industrial Hygienist or other professional knowledgeable in respiratory protective devices.

In 1975, NIOSH and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) as part of the Standards Completion Program developed a Respirator Decision Logic. That Logic incorporated fit factor data developed by the Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) under contract to NIOSH and incorporated requirements from 30 CFR 11.

The Decision Logic was modified by NIOSH in 1987 to include:

1. the NIOSH respirator carcinogen policy,

2. respiratory protective devices developed since 1975, and

3. a revision of assigned protection factors for those respirators for which valid workplace protection factor studies had been performed.

The selection of a specific respirator should be made by individuals knowledgeable of the limitations associated with each class of respirator (see Chapter 2), and familiar with the actual work environment including job tasks to be performed. For example, mobility of the worker and temperature and humidity of the work environment should all be considered in making an adequate respirator selection.

III. NIOSH Respirator Decision Logic

The NIOSH Respirator Decision Logic is reproduced as part of Appendix E of this document. This Logic contains a set of questions which will lead the user to the proper respirator selection table and identifies the criteria necessary to determine the classes of respirators which will provide adequate protection.

IV. NIOSH Certified Equipment List

The NIOSH Certified Equipment List (NCE) is published annually and lists the coal mine dust personal sampler units and respirators certified by NIOSH as well as provides updated information on the products, certifications, respirator complaints and problems, and NIOSH respirator policy.

In 1985, the format of this publication was modified. Respirators are now listed by specific certification class. General cautions and limitations for each certification class are listed (see page 84). However, these limitations are by no means all inclusive. The respirator manufacturer may also identify further limitations or cautions for their respirators. In addition, regulatory agencies may also place a limit on the use of respirators in their standards. An example of the listing for entry into and escape open-circuit SCBA is given on page 85.

Single, complimentary copies of the NCE will be provided by NIOSH while the supply lasts. Multiple copies can be ordered from the Government Printing Office (GPO). Requests for single copies should be sent to:

Publication Dissemination, DSDTT
NIOSH
4676 Columbia Parkway
Cincinnati, Ohio 45226-1998

 

 

EXAMPLE OF LISTING FROM NIOSH CERTIFIED EQUIPMENT LIST

A. Self-contained Breathing Apparatus

1. Entry Into and Escape

a. Open circuit pressure demand

Approval

Certified as approved for respiratory protection during entry into or escape from oxygen deficient atmospheres, gases and vapors.

Limitations

Use only for temperatures above the temperature listed on approval label.

Approved only when compressed air reservoir is fully charged with air meeting the requirements of the Compressed Gas Association Specification G-7.1 for Type 1, Grade D air, or equivalent specifications.

The air container shall meet applicable DOT specifications.

Use adequate skin protection when worn in gases or vapors that poison by skin absorption.

Refer to certification label and instruction and maintenance manuals for additional information on use and maintenance of these respirators.

In making renewals and repairs, parts identical with those furnished by the manufacturer under the pertinent approval shall be maintained.

Demand mode shall be used only when donning apparatus.

This respirator shall be selected, fitted, used and maintained in accordance with Mine Safety and Health Administration and other applicable regulations.

Recommendations

NIOSH recommends that SCBA be inspected weekly if stored and immediately before use, if used regularly, for breathing gas pressure.

 

SCBA ENTRY INTO AND ESCAPE OPEN CIRCUIT PRESSURE DEMAND

Approval Number
TC-13-F-
Approval Issued to Model Number(s) Service Life (min.) Facepiece Type Regular Position
30 MSA 95069
96338
461696
461704
461946
461947
463814
463815
463831
463833
466209
470444
470445
470448
470449
30 FF Bm
40 Scott 900014-00
900014-01/05/06/12/30/31/39/50/51 900214-00/01/05/06/50/ 51

 

30 FF Bm
42 Scott 900015-00
900015-01/05/06

 

15 FF Bm
45 USD 9038-20*
9038-22*/70*/72*
9838-22/70*/72*
9848-20/22
9849-20*/22*
U9038-00
U9838-00/02
M9838-20*

 

30 FF Bm
47 MSA 95063
460262
461697
461703
15 FF Bm

 

Return to NIOSH Guide Table of Contents

tracking image